Skip to main content

Family Law Matters Scotland

Relocation of Children

When faced with a parent’s request to allow their child to relocate out with the UK, it is settled law in Scotland that the court’s decision is based solely on the best interests of the child irrespective of how much time the child spends with each parent. In England, the leading case of Payne v Payne [2001] EWCA Civ 166, on the other hand, confirmed that, whilst the child’s best interests were paramount, great weight had to be accorded to the reasonable plans of a parent with a residence order. Having said that, although this decision has not yet been overturned by the Supreme Court or by the enactment of new legislation, the English courts can now be seen to be moving more towards the Scottish “presumption free” approach.

Relocation was the main focus of the recent case of W v W [2023] CSOH 72 where the father opposed the mother’s request for their 3-year-old son to relocate to France. The father had been born and raised in Scotland. His wider family all lived close by. The mother had been born in France but had moved to Scotland where she had lived since 2011. The mother’s extended family lived in France. The parties had separated in December 2021. By June 2022 the parties had equal care of their son and, at that point, the father agreed to allow relocation to France in the summer of 2023. In May 2023 he withdrew his consent.

The parties were agreed that each parent gave an excellent standard of care to the child and that he had devoted families in Scotland and France. They also agreed that he was happy at nursery and that he was thriving, happy and well adjusted.

Lord Stuart presided over the case and confirmed the test for relocation cases, namely that the child’s welfare was paramount and that the court had to weigh up all relevant factors in the case before making a decision. The Scottish approach is entirely “presumption free” and no particular factor has greater weight than any other. Everything depends on the child involved and their unique circumstances.

Lord Stuart confirmed that it was for the mother to show that (1) relocation would be in the best interests of the child and (2) that from the child’s perspective, it would be better to allow relocation than to make no order. It was of no consequence that the father had previously agreed to the relocation.

When assessing the evidence, Lord Stuart based his decision on five main areas :- 1) relationship with parents, including maintenance of contact, 2) wider family relationships and childcare, including family support, 3) employment, 4) accommodation, and 5) education.

Lord Stuart found the position to be largely neutral in relation to the areas of employment, accommodation, and education. However, the evidence in relation to the first and second areas shaped his decision. He found if the child relocated, it would fundamentally undermine both the important and beneficial presence of the father in the child’s life and the child’s desire for physical contact with him. The holiday contact and indirect contact proposed by the mother was a poor substitute and not in the child’s best interests. For his Lordship, the reduction of the child’s relationship with his father and the role his father played in his life would be the most significant disadvantage to the child. He also found that relocation would significantly reduce the benefits that the child derived from his interactions with the father’s extended family.

This case is a reminder that pursuing an order for relocation will be an extremely challenging task where there is a close relationship with the other parent. As Lord Stuart said in W v W, in that situation, there would have to be clear evidence of significant benefits to the child in other areas before the court could conclude that the negative effect on the relationship between the left behind parent and the child was sufficiently offset to demonstrate that relocation was in the child’s best interests. Examples may be where the child has particular medical or educational needs that would be best served in the other country.

For advice and assistance in relation to child relocation, and all other family law matters, please contact us on 0141 420 2403 or email us at reception@flmscotland.co.uk. 

The content of this webpage is for information only and is not intended to be construed as legal advice and should not be treated as a substitute for specific advice. Family Law Matters Scotland LLP accepts no responsibility for the content of any third party website to which this webpage refers.

 

Morven joined Family Law Matters in 2023. She has practised exclusively in the field of family law since qualifying as a solicitor in 2003.

N.B Please note the contents of this Blog do not constitute any form of legal advice and you should always obtain individual advice as to your rights from a family lawyer.