Skip to main content

Family Law Matters Scotland

Can a child currently be returned to Ukraine under the 1980 Hague Convention? PART 2

It has long been recognised that successfully defending a Petition for the return of a child to their country of origin under Article 13(1)(b) of the Hague Convention will very much be the exception and not the rule. This is known as the “grave risk” exception and gives the court discretion not to return a child where there is a grave risk that their return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place the child in an intolerable situation. The Convention is based on mutual respect between signatory countries and the confidence that they have in their respective legal systems to protect individuals who live there. My colleague, Marisa Cullen, recently discussed the recent English case of Q v. R [2022] EWHC 2961 (Fam) where this was exactly the basis of the respondent parent’s Article 13(b) defence (https://www.familylawmattersscotland.co.uk/2022/12/12/can-a-child-currently-be-returned-to-ukraine-under-1980-hague-convention/ ). The child had been wrongfully removed from Ukraine. On the face of it, this was exactly the type of case where we would expect the Article 13(b) defence to succeed.  However, the Judge stayed true to the Convention and ordered return.

However, on 17 March 2023, Dexter Dias, KC (sitting as High Court Judge) of the Family Division of the High Court of Justice issued his decision in the case of [2023] EWHC 602 (Fam), in which he allowed an applicant father to withdraw his Petition for the return of his two children to Kyiv, Ukraine. During the course of the father’s application, things had evolved for the worse in Kyiv. The court therefore had to assess if it was in the interests of justice to allow him to withdraw the application and, as such, the Judge delivered a judgement on the mother’s Article 13(b) defence only. The Judge found that given the regular missile strikes in Kyiv, which were targeting civilian buildings and infrastructure that there was an unquestionable risk of physical harm to the children.

Following the finding that there was risk of harm, Dias, KC went on to consider whether the risk could be “ameliorated” or sufficiently mitigated to enable the children to return to Kyiv safely. The Judge found that it could not. Nothing could be done to influence the military strategy of Vladimir Putin or the Russian state. The court concluded that Kyiv was an ongoing target and the applicant was permitted to withdraw his application.

This was an eminently sensible decision based on the facts of the case though a terrible situation for the family. The Judge made clear, however, that this the Judgment in no way reflected a blanket policy to the situation in Ukraine and that the Judgement had been issued following “an acutely fact-specific risk assessment about the safety of two children amid a troubling, complex and ever-evolving international conflict involving two sovereign states on the other side of the continent” (para 32-33). Accordingly, as can be seen by both this case and Q v R, it will be, by no means, a foregone conclusion that a return to Ukraine will be refused and it will depend completely on the individual circumstances of that case.

Morven joined Family Law Matters in 2023. She has practised exclusively in the field of family law since qualifying as a solicitor in 2003.

N.B Please note the contents of this Blog do not constitute any form of legal advice and you should always obtain individual advice as to your rights from a family lawyer.