Skip to main content

Family Law Matters Scotland

1980 Hague Convention and Grave Risk

In my last blog, I noted that successfully defending a Petition for the return of a child to their country of origin under Article 13(1)(b) of the Hague Convention of 25 October 1980 on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction is very much the exception and not the rule. This is known as the “grave risk” exception and gives the court discretion not to return a child where there is a grave risk that their return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place the child in an intolerable situation.

However, we now have a recent Scottish case where the defence succeeded. In March, the Inner House of the Court of Session (the Appeal Court) issued their judgment in the case of AD v SD [2023] CSIH 17. Here the mother of two children, who were habitually resident in Illinois, USA, had wrongfully retained them in Scotland. The mother lodged evidence of psychological, physical, and sexual abuse that she had been subjected to by AD and submitted that a return to the USA would put the children at grave risk. The defence failed initially, and the Judge ordered return.   

However, the mother appealed to the Inner House who overturned the Judge’s decision. They referred to the test set out in the UK Supreme Court case of E [2012] 1 AC 144 which states that where the “grave risk” defence founding on domestic abuse is pled, a staged approach is required. Firstly, the court needs to ask, if the disputed allegations are true, would there be a grave risk that the child would be exposed to physical or psychological harm or otherwise placed in an intolerable situation? If it concludes that there would be such a grave risk, the court must then ask if the child can be effectively protected against the risk. Further, the court needs to consider whether the protective measures require to cover more than the immediate future because the need for effective protection may persist. This was not the approach taken by the Judge at first instance who only considered whether the protective measures in place would be sufficient in the short term.

In AD v SD the Inner House found, on the basis of extensive evidence presented to the first instance Judge, that SD had established a grave risk that harm to her of the most severe kind (physical injury or worse) would occur in the event that she and the children were returned to Illinois. That would place the children in an intolerable situation, as would repetition of the unrelenting harassment and intimidation that SD had been subjected to by AD.

The Inner House then had to assess whether the proposed protective measures would effectively protect the children from that risk, namely various legal remedies available to SD in the Illinois courts. They found that it would be unlikely that AD would comply with any orders made by the Illinois courts given his persistent breaches of an order already made in his own jurisdiction’s proceedings, coupled with his reluctance to agree to protective orders on the children’s return. On that basis they stated that it would be inconceivable that a return would be ordered.  

This case was, of course, very fact specific and sadly involved significant abuse but it acts as a reminder that the defence is available to use for the protection of children in Hague cases where appropriate.

For advice on international parental child abduction or any other family law matters, please contact us on 0141 420 2430 or email us at reception@flmscotland.co.uk.

Morven joined Family Law Matters in 2023. She has practised exclusively in the field of family law since qualifying as a solicitor in 2003.

N.B Please note the contents of this Blog do not constitute any form of legal advice and you should always obtain individual advice as to your rights from a family lawyer.