Can a child currently be returned to Ukraine under the 1980 Hague Convention?
I have had a number of enquiries from parents of children who have come to the UK under the Family Visa Scheme, that the UK has put in place for Ukrainians. As yet however, none of the enquiries that I have had have proceeded to Court. To my knowledge, the Scottish Court has yet to consider the matter.
The English Court in the case of Q v. R [2022] EWHC 2961 (Fam) was faced with this scenario. A Ukrainian mother sought the return of her child to Ukraine from England. Two “defences“ were raised on behalf of the Respondent father (1) that the 5 year old child in this case was habitually resident in England at the date of the wrongful retention and therefore the 1980 Convention did not apply and (2) in the event the 1980 Hague Convention did apply Article 13(b) where there is a grave risk that the child’s return would expose him to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place him in an intolerable situation applies, and a non-return should be the outcome.
The Judge having decided, on balance, that the child was habitually resident in Ukraine at the date of his wrongful retention and therefore the 1980 Convention was invoked, moved on to discuss the very relevant Article 13(b) defence. As can be imagined, the father’s case was very much that given Ukraine is currently in the midst of a war, that the Article 13(b) defence was very clearly made out.
The Judge was clear that (in his words) “The Authorities indicate a need to focus upon the circumstances of this child returning to that country, and the risks which arise on their return and thereafter. Protective measures are a relevant consideration; they can take many forms”. He then went on to analyse evidence that had been lodged by both parties but particularly was careful to take account of the situation on the ground in Ukraine. Ultimately, the mother’s response to the Article 13(b) defence was that the town in which she was intending to return the child to in Ukraine had not been reached by the conflict as it was located in a very western point of Ukraine, it was functioning reasonably normal with schools open, shops open, the Court system functioning etc. Crucially the mother provided undertakings, one of which was that if the conflict were to extend towards the town she was taking the child to, she would remove the child from Ukraine. The Judge therefore found that an Article 13(b) defence had not been established and ordered the return of the child to Ukraine.
While perhaps a surprising Judgment to some, the Judge was very clear that the 1980 Hague Convention and the pertaining case law, is very clear that Judges in these cases have to look at the individual child and the circumstances pertaining to that child. Even where on the face of it a return to Ukraine would have seemed unlikely, in the circumstances of this particular child allowed the Judge to order the return.

Marisa joined Family Law Matters Scotland LLP as a partner in 2021. Marisa has been practicing law since 2005. She is double accredited by the Law Society of Scotland as a specialist in both family law and child law.
N.B Please note the contents of this Blog do not constitute any form of legal advice and you should always obtain individual advice as to your rights from a family lawyer.