Skip to main content

Family Law Matters Scotland

Categories
Children Divorce International Family Law

What is the likelihood of me being able to get my ex-partner’s parental rights and responsibilities removed

wHAT IS THE LIKELIHOOD OR ME BEING ABLE TO GET MY EX-PARTNERS' PARENTAL RIGHTS AND RESPONSIBILITIES REMOVED?

The answer to this question is likely to be “not high” though it will, of course, depend on the circumstances of your case. An order depriving a parent of their responsibilities and rights was described by Sheriff Reid in the recent case of AB v CD [2024] SC KDY 2 as “a (or perhaps the) most profound interference with a party’s rights under Art.8 of the European Convention on Human Rights”. Accordingly, the Court must be satisfied that the order sought is proportionate and there is no less draconian, but equally effective way, of securing the best interests of the child.

The parties in AB v CD were the parents of an 11-year-old child – “Andrew”. Following the parties’ separation in 2017, Andrew lived with his mother and had contact with his father. In 2018 the court made an order reducing that contact to nil following allegations that the father had assaulted and sexually assaulted the mother and her three older children (not the father’s children). He was ultimately convicted of these offences and imprisoned. The pursuer sought to remove the father’s parental rights and responsibilities (PRR) under s.11(2)(a) of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 on the basis that the continuation of these rights caused her stress and anxiety and that Andrew had no relationship with his father and would not miss it.

As with any application for an order under s.11 of the 1995 Act, the Sheriff considered the case on the basis that Andrew’s best interests were his paramount consideration. In his judgment, his Lordship found that it was not better for Andrew that the father’s parental responsibilities and rights were removed and refused the order. The principal factors that were relevant to the Sheriff’s decision were as follows :-

1.  The continuation of the father’s PRR did not pose a direct threat to Andrew

2. The mother’s desire for a clean break from the father carried little weight

3. There was no evidence that the mother’s stress and anxiety about the continuation of the father’s PRR was such that she had a diagnosable psychological or psychiatric condition

4. There was no evidence of a wider effect upon the pursuer’s family.

5. There was no evidence of an adverse effect on Andrew

6. That the order were made, Andrew would be legally orphaned

As a fall-back position the mother had asked the Sheriff to suspend the father’s PRR. Sheriff Reid refused to suspend the right of residence as doing so would make no difference as the mother already had a residence order. Similarly, he refused to suspend the father’s right and responsibility to maintain personal relations with Andrew given the terms of the existing contact order.

Sheriff Reid did agree, however, to suspend the father’s right and responsibility to act as Andrew’s legal representative along with the father’s responsibility to safeguard and promote Andrew’s health, development and welfare. He also suspended the father’s right to control, direct or guide Andrew. The corresponding responsibility was not suspended as it was effectively already limited by the contact order.

Finally, he ordered that, given the defender would have no direct role in Andrew’s life, that the pursuer should be entitled to remove Andrew from the United Kingdom without the defender’s consent.

For Sheriff Reid the orders struck the appropriate balance between protecting the child, giving the mother the certainty and security, she needed but, did not close the door entirely on the possibility of the defender and Andrew re-establishing a relationship in the future. This may be a surprising outcome to some readers and also acts as a reminder that robust evidence, medical evidence in particular, will be needed if the parent seeking to deprive the other parent of their PRR is claiming that the impact on them will have an indirect adverse impact on the child. 

For advice and assistance in relation to parental rights and responsibilities, and all other family law matters, please contact us on 0141 420 2403 or email us at reception@flmscotland.co.uk. 

The content of this webpage is for information only and is not intended to be construed as legal advice and should not be treated as a substitute for specific advice. Family Law Matters Scotland LLP accepts no responsibility for the content of any third party website to which this webpage refers.

 

Morven joined Family Law Matters in 2023. She has practised exclusively in the field of family law since qualifying as a solicitor in 2003.

N.B Please note the contents of this Blog do not constitute any form of legal advice and you should always obtain individual advice as to your rights from a family lawyer.

Categories
Divorce International Family Law

How will our assets be divided on Divorce/Dissolution?

How will our assets be divided on Divorce/Dissolution?

When married or civil partnered individuals separate, the law which applies to the division of their assets is found in the Family Law (Scotland) Act 1985. In terms of that Act, the parties’ matrimonial /partnership property should be shared fairly. “Fairly” can often mean equally but there is provision in the Act for unequal sharing in certain circumstances.  However, such unequal sharing is entirely at the discretion of the Judge or Sheriff who is dealing with the case. Often, they will find that the respective parties’ arguments for unequal sharing negate each other and will simply order equal sharing of the assets.

 

In fact, this is exactly what happened in the recent case at Aberdeen Sheriff Court, LM v AM [2023] SC ABE 34. Here there were three unequal sharing arguments which all failed and the Sheriff found that the net assets should be shared equally. Firstly, the husband argued that the value of the matrimonial home should be shared unequally due to pre-marriage funds that he had injected into the purchase of an earlier property which the parties had bought. However, the Sheriff accepted the wife’s evidence that she had provided a largely equal sum. Accordingly, taking a broad-brush approach, the Sheriff held that the matrimonial home should be sold and the net free proceeds shared equally.

It is possible to seek unequal sharing where one party will bear more than half of the costs associated with caring for a child of the parties who is under 16. The wife made this argument but provided no evidence of those costs or the accommodation that she would require to acquire for her and her son to live in. On the basis of her earnings, the Sheriff was satisfied that an equal sharing of the assets would be sufficient for her to secure suitable accommodation in any event and found no basis on which to order unequal sharing.

The third argument related to the parties’ heritable properties. The wife argued that she had been economically disadvantaged as the parties’ jointly owned flat had been rented out and the husband had retained all of the rent. The husband claimed he had been disadvantaged as he had paid the outgoings on the property to which the wife had made no contribution. The Sheriff found that the husband had paid significantly more than the wife in relation to the combined mortgage payments on the flat and the matrimonial home whilst the wife had had exclusive occupation of the matrimonial home since separation. On that basis and employing his “broad axe”, he accordingly found that there should be equal sharing in relation to the flat.  

The Sheriff commented at various points that the evidence was either non-existent, vague, or unsatisfactory. This case is therefore very much a cautionary reminder to anyone contemplating a litigation where they are arguing for more than a one-half share of the assets. Due to the breadth of the Sheriff’s discretion in this regard, this is very risky, particularly where you do not have robust evidence to support your case. If a party takes a case all the way to a final hearing and is unsuccessful, there is also the significant risk that they will be found liable for the other party’s judicial expenses as well as having to meet all of the costs related to their own case. The cost implications for parties are, accordingly, considerable, not to mention the polarising effect that the litigation will likely have on them. This is particularly undesirable for parties with children whom they may be co-parenting for some time to come.

Court should always be the last resort. there are many other ways to navigate the financial aspects of a separation, for example; mediation, negotiation, collaborative law, or arbitration. It is also always important to consult a family law specialist prior to getting married or entering a Civil Partnership to discuss the drafting of a Pre-Nuptial Agreement. This can significantly limit the scope for unequal sharing arguments, and the associated expense and update, in the event of a future separation. 

For advice and assistance in relation to separation and divorce, and all other family law matters, please contact us on 0141 420 2403 or email us at receptin@flmscotland.co.uk. 

The content of this webpage is for information only and is not intended to be construed as legal advice and should not be treated as a substitute for specific advice. Family Law Matters Scotland LLP accepts no responsibility for the content of any third party website to which this webpage refers.

 

Morven joined Family Law Matters in 2023. She has practised exclusively in the field of family law since qualifying as a solicitor in 2003.

N.B Please note the contents of this Blog do not constitute any form of legal advice and you should always obtain individual advice as to your rights from a family lawyer.