Relocation of Children : M v A 2023 [CSOH] 80
In my last blog about relocation, I looked at the case of W v W [2023] CSOH 72 in which Lord Stuart refused a mother’s application for her son to relocate from Scotland to France. In M v A [2023] CSOH 80 Lord Stuart was faced with another relocation application, this time within Scotland, and in quite unusual circumstances. However, unusual as it was, the test that Lord Stuart had to apply when considering the application was still the usual welfare test and whether the relocation would be in the best interests of the children or not.
In M v A, the mother was the primary carer of the children aged 2 and 4. Before January 2023, the father, who was making the application for the children to relocate, had exercised intermittent contact with the children who had lived in Aberdeen with their mother since September 2022. From January 2023 the father began exercising alternate weekend contact with them in Glasgow. However, unlike in most relocation cases, he was not also seeking a residence order and agreed that the mother should continue to be the primary carer. Therefore, unusually, in practical terms, he was not only seeking relocation of the children but of their mother too.
Lord Stuart refused the application on the basis that the children were well settled in Aberdeen and based this decision on a number of factors. He considered that they lived in appropriate accommodation. Further, their mother was is in good employment in Aberdeen, with prospects of promotion and was therefore in a secure position to provide for the children. In terms of education, he found that the children attended a reputable nursery in Aberdeen where they were doing well and from which they would progress along with their peers in the usual way. He also found that no better health provision existed in Glasgow compared to Aberdeen.
The children’s mother was a Latvian national and in Aberdeen she and the children were part of a community of adults and children who supported both their Scottish and Latvian heritages. This was an important factor in favour of staying in Aberdeen as this could not be replicated in Glasgow. Further, the children’s paternal grandparents lived in St Andrews which was equidistant between Glasgow and Aberdeen and so were able to be a meaningful part of the children’s lives whether they were in Aberdeen or Glasgow.
Whilst Lord Stuart accepted that the distance between the children and the father did have a negative impact on the children’s ability to have direct contact with him, the father had said in evidence that he would consider moving to Aberdeen if he was unsuccessful in the application. Further, the father’s employment was temporary and his home was not his own but rather was owned by a family trust. This was in direct contrast to the mother’s home and employment situation which provided a solid and stable environment for the children.
Accordingly, Lord Stuart saw little, if any, benefit in requiring the children to relocate to Glasgow and was of the view that their circumstances could be improved by the pursuer taking action rather than the children. Throughout the evidence Lord Stuart considered that the father’s application appeared to be based on what he wanted as opposed to what was objectively in his children’s best interests.
This case reminds us that if children are thriving in the status quo, then an application to relocate them elsewhere is very likely to be unsuccessful. It is important that clients are aware of the hurdles they will face if they wish to raise an action for relocation given the significant cost implications of doing so, not to mention the potential destruction of any remaining relationship with the other parent and the ramifications of that for continued co-parenting.
For advice and assistance in relation to child relocation, and all other family law matters, please contact us on 0141 420 2403 or email us at reception@flmscotland.co.uk.

Morven joined Family Law Matters in 2023. She has practised exclusively in the field of family law since qualifying as a solicitor in 2003.
N.B Please note the contents of this Blog do not constitute any form of legal advice and you should always obtain individual advice as to your rights from a family lawyer.