Skip to main content

Family Law Matters Scotland

Categories
Children International Family Law

Can a child currently be returned to Ukraine under 1980 Hague Convention? Part 2

Can a child currently be returned to Ukraine under the 1980 Hague Convention? PART 2

It has long been recognised that successfully defending a Petition for the return of a child to their country of origin under Article 13(1)(b) of the Hague Convention will very much be the exception and not the rule. This is known as the “grave risk” exception and gives the court discretion not to return a child where there is a grave risk that their return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place the child in an intolerable situation. The Convention is based on mutual respect between signatory countries and the confidence that they have in their respective legal systems to protect individuals who live there. My colleague, Marisa Cullen, recently discussed the recent English case of Q v. R [2022] EWHC 2961 (Fam) where this was exactly the basis of the respondent parent’s Article 13(b) defence (https://www.familylawmattersscotland.co.uk/2022/12/12/can-a-child-currently-be-returned-to-ukraine-under-1980-hague-convention/ ). The child had been wrongfully removed from Ukraine. On the face of it, this was exactly the type of case where we would expect the Article 13(b) defence to succeed.  However, the Judge stayed true to the Convention and ordered return.

However, on 17 March 2023, Dexter Dias, KC (sitting as High Court Judge) of the Family Division of the High Court of Justice issued his decision in the case of [2023] EWHC 602 (Fam), in which he allowed an applicant father to withdraw his Petition for the return of his two children to Kyiv, Ukraine. During the course of the father’s application, things had evolved for the worse in Kyiv. The court therefore had to assess if it was in the interests of justice to allow him to withdraw the application and, as such, the Judge delivered a judgement on the mother’s Article 13(b) defence only. The Judge found that given the regular missile strikes in Kyiv, which were targeting civilian buildings and infrastructure that there was an unquestionable risk of physical harm to the children.

Following the finding that there was risk of harm, Dias, KC went on to consider whether the risk could be “ameliorated” or sufficiently mitigated to enable the children to return to Kyiv safely. The Judge found that it could not. Nothing could be done to influence the military strategy of Vladimir Putin or the Russian state. The court concluded that Kyiv was an ongoing target and the applicant was permitted to withdraw his application.

This was an eminently sensible decision based on the facts of the case though a terrible situation for the family. The Judge made clear, however, that this the Judgment in no way reflected a blanket policy to the situation in Ukraine and that the Judgement had been issued following “an acutely fact-specific risk assessment about the safety of two children amid a troubling, complex and ever-evolving international conflict involving two sovereign states on the other side of the continent” (para 32-33). Accordingly, as can be seen by both this case and Q v R, it will be, by no means, a foregone conclusion that a return to Ukraine will be refused and it will depend completely on the individual circumstances of that case.

Morven joined Family Law Matters in 2023. She has practised exclusively in the field of family law since qualifying as a solicitor in 2003.

N.B Please note the contents of this Blog do not constitute any form of legal advice and you should always obtain individual advice as to your rights from a family lawyer.

Categories
Children International Family Law

Do I need consent from my ex to take my child on holiday?

Do I need consent from my ex to take my child on holiday?

 

Both the Easter and Summer school holiday season is fast approaching. For many separated parents childcare arrangements over school holidays can be tricky to agree with the other parent and on top of this there can be anxiety as to whether you need the consent of the other parent before taking your child on holiday. 

What does the law say? 

While it would usually be of benefit to both parents and any child involved that agreement is made in relation to holidays, (and if there is a minute of agreement or court order regulating contact and/or contact during school holidays then that should be followed) legally there is a difference between taking a child on holiday within the UK and out with the UK. Section 2(3) of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 states that, unless there is a court order regulating the matter, no person is entitled to remove a child who is habitually resident in Scotland out with the UK without the consent of the other parent (presuming they have Parental Rights and Parental Responsibilities). Such rule applies up until a child is 16. 

If I am a parent and I do not wish to consent to my child going on holiday out with the UK but I think they are going to be taken anyway, is there anything I can do?  

You may have evidence to apply to the court in Scotland for a protective order called an “interdict against removal” where the court could be asked to prohibit the child being removed either from the Sheriffdom or more usually from Scotland. Taken together with a possible order for surrender of passports and a UK wide port stop, such orders could prevent the child leaving the UK. This is a rather extreme measure if it is clear that the child is only going on holiday. However often in such cases there can be a question mark as to whether the child is being legitimately taken on holiday or that the intention is that the child is being permanently relocated from Scotland under the guise of a holiday. 

Is it a criminal offence for a parent to take a child out with the UK on holiday without the other parent’s consent?  

I have seen media reports from legal commentators getting this question wrong. The answer lies in the Child Abduction Act 1984. The confusion appears to lie in the fact that the 1984 Act is divided into different sections for Scotland and for England and Wales. In England and Wales, a criminal offence can be committed if the child’s removal from the UK is without the consent of a person with parental responsibility regardless of whether any court order is in place. However, this is not the same as the criminal law in Scotland. In Scotland, a criminal offence of child abduction can only be committed where a person connected with a child under 16 takes or keeps that child out with the UK in breach of a UK court order dealing with the custody of the child or prohibiting a child’s removal from the UK.  

My child has been taken on holiday and has not been returned, what can I do? 

This depends on the country that the child has been taken to. If the country that the child has been taken to and the UK operates the 1980 Hague Convention, then there is a mechanism to seek the return of the child. Even if it is a country that does not operate under the umbrella of the 1980 Hague Convention, the Scottish court may order return of the child. There are defences available in both cases to parents who have taken the child out of the country. 

If you require any family law assistance with any topics arising from this blog then please contact our Marisa Cullen.  

 
Marisa Cullen

Marisa joined Family Law Matters Scotland LLP as a partner in 2021. Marisa has been practicing law since 2005. She is double accredited by the Law Society of Scotland as a specialist in both family law and child law.

N.B Please note the contents of this Blog do not constitute any form of legal advice and you should always obtain individual advice as to your rights from a family lawyer.

Categories
Children Cohabitation Divorce International Family Law

What to Expect in your First Meeting with your Family Lawyer

What to Expect in your First Meeting with your Family Lawyer

The breakdown of a relationship is a difficult and daunting time for everyone concerned and here at Family Law Matters Scotland we aim to guide you through every step of the process. It may be the first time that you have ever consulted a lawyer and it may therefore be helpful to consider how your first meeting will be conducted and how you can best prepare.

Step 1: Legal Advice

If you are experiencing difficulties in your relationship, it is a good idea to obtain specialist family law advice as soon as possible. Every situation is different, and it is important that you obtain legal advice on your specific circumstances so that you are aware of all your options. Your solicitor will then be able to assist you in formulating a plan as to how best to progress with a separation if that is what you choose to do.

Your solicitor will discuss the various ways you can deal with your separation (link to our resolution options page) which include:

  • Negotiation
  • Collaboration
  • Mediation
  • Arbitration
  • Litigation

Step 2: Childcare Arrangements

If children are involved, your solicitor will want to understand what the current childcare arrangements are and how you would like these to operate going forward. When you are considering what would work best for the children you will need to consider the practicalities of the situation such as where you and your spouse/civil partner/ex-partner live in relation to each other and the school, and what activities the children have on certain days.

It may be that you have already come to a mutual agreement on this matter or your solicitor may write to your spouse/civil partner/ex-partner or their solicitor to negotiate the specifics of these arrangements.

It is important to consider that all arrangements should be in the child’s best interests and that their views should be taken into consideration as far as possible and in accordance with their age and maturity. Cooperation and communication between parents are always encouraged but it is recognised that in some cases this can be very difficult due to the history of the relationship. You can discuss with your solicitor the various ways that you could communicate with your spouse/civil partner/ex-partner and decide what would work best for you.

Step 3: Finances

Spouses/Civil Partners

Your solicitor will also want to discuss the financial aspects of your separation with you. If you are married or in a civil partnership, your solicitor will ask you for details of the assets and debts (in your joint and sole names)  that you had at the date you separated. This will allow them to work out the potential extent of the property which is to be divided between you and your spouse/civil partner. They will also request information regarding your income and outgoings. It will be helpful if you have details of the relevant values of your assets and liabilities at your date of separation but this is not essential.  

The starting point of the law on the division of the net assets of spouses/civil partners is that these should be divided fairly which often means equally. However, there can be special circumstances which justify an unequal division. There is no exhaustive list of what may constitute special circumstances. Accordingly, your solicitor will ask you some questions about this to check whether an unequal sharing may be justified in your case.

Former Co-habitants

The law applying to the division of property for couples who were not married or in a civil partnership is different. The legislation for former cohabitants provides that a former partner can make a claim against the other party for economic disadvantage suffered as a result of the contributions they made during the relationship for the benefit of the other party or any child, where that disadvantage has not been counter balanced by any economic advantage gained.

Accordingly, your solicitor will ask you some question about the respective financial positions you and your former partner had at the start of your relationship and at the end and the contributions that you each made during the relationship. That will then allow them to guide you on whether you have a claim or indeed the likelihood of a claim being made against you.

Unmarried partners only have one year from the date of separation to raise any claim in court, The court will not accept a claim out with the one-year deadline and therefore if the action is not raised in time, the ability to make a claim will be lost entirely. Accordingly early advice is essential particularly where you think your former partner may argue for an earlier date of separation.

Conclusion

Your solicitor’s job is to guide you through the legal aspects of your separation and divorce and to give you practical advice on how to achieve the best outcome for you based on the particular circumstances of your case. Through this process, there can be a lot of information for you to digest and we appreciate how overwhelming that can be. Please feel free to ask as many questions as you need and for your solicitor to clarify anything that is not clear.

At Family Law Matters we are pleased to continue to offer Initial Consultations in person, via video call or via phone calls for a fixed fee of £240.00.

To arrange your initial consultation for advice on separation, divorce/dissolution and other family law matters please contact us on 0141 420 2430 or email us at reception@flmscotland.co.uk.

Categories
Children Cohabitation Divorce International Family Law

International Women’s Day 2023

International Women's Day 2023

Happy International Women’s Day 2023! Over 100 years ago International Women’s Day was first celebrated, with the aim to achieve equality for all people across the world. As we reflect on this day, we are proud to celebrate growing gender equality, including within the Scottish Legal Profession, and are reflecting on women in positions of power and those who inspire us from Lady Wise, Scottish Supreme Courts Judge to Malala Yousafzai, Activist and Nobel Prize Winner. 

We believe that International Women’s Day is also an important time to remember those who continue to go unheard and who are prevented from reaching their full potential as basic rights like health and education remain unrecognised for many women around the world. It is essential that we continue to do all that we can to pave the way for the still much needed change for these women.