Skip to main content

Family Law Matters Scotland

Categories
Children International Family Law

Surrogacy in Scotland

Surrogacy in Scotland

Last week Paris Hilton announced that she had welcomed a baby boy via surrogate. From Priyanka Chopra to the Kardashians, Paris is just one of the latest in a stream of celebrities who have opted for this less traditional route of becoming a parent. Recently viewers of Made in Chelsea have been able to follow Ollie Locke and his husband Gareth’s surrogacy journey here in the UK.

What is surrogacy?

Surrogacy is when a woman carries a child for another person or couple who want to become parents. Surrogacy can involve a range of family compositions and various different medical methods. It can involve the surrogate carrying a child that is genetically hers or the genetic product of the commissioning couple.

Is surrogacy legal?

Surrogacy is legal in Scotland, and throughout the UK provided that it is done on a non-commercial basis (in that no payments except ‘reasonable expenses’ are to be made in exchange for the surrogacy arrangement). However, there are a range of often complex legal issues which a prospective surrogate and prospective intended parents should consider before proceeding with such an arrangement.

Legal parents:

UK legislation provides that the legal parents of a child born through surrogacy are the surrogate mother (regardless of whether she is genetically related to the child or not) and her spouse or civil partner. If the gestational mother is not married or in a civil partnership, then the genetic father will ordinarily be the legal father.

Currently, the surrogate mother has the legal right to keep the child when they are born – even if a contract has been signed and any expenses paid. Until a court order is made, a surrogate mother is treated as the child’s mother. 

Therefore generally, the intended parent/s will require to seek a Parental Order from the court in order for parentage to be transferred to them.

Surrogacy Arrangements/Parental Orders:

Surrogacy arrangements and applications for Parental Orders are regulated by the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008. At present, surrogacy agreements are not legally binding and irrespective of whether paperwork has been signed, the surrogate mother, and indeed the intended parents, can change their minds right up until the child is delivered. Accordingly, there is currently no legal protection for the intended parents to prevent the surrogate mother from failing to deliver the baby to them following successful fertilisation treatment. That being said, in most cases the courts have ruled in favour of parents seeking to uphold a surrogacy agreement.

It should be noted that this area of law is currently the subject of a joint consultation by the Scottish Law Commission and the Law Commission of England & Wales.

For advice on surrogacy, please contact us on 0141 420 2430 or email us at reception@flmscotland.co.uk.

Categories
Children Cohabitation Divorce International Family Law

Morven Douglas Joins Firm as Legal Director

Morven Douglas joins Firm as Legal Director

Family Law Matters are pleased to welcome Morven Douglas to our firm as a Legal Director. Specialising in family law for almost 20 years, Morven advises individuals on a range of family law matters including separation, high value divorce and cohabitation claims, and has a particular interest in child related matters with an international element.

On joining the firm, 
 said “I am delighted to be appointed as a Legal Director with Family Law Matters. The firm has an outstanding reputation as one of the top family law firms in Scotland and I am really looking forward to embarking on my new role.”
 
Karen Gailey, Partner added “Our whole team is thrilled to welcome a family lawyer of Morven’s calibre and we know she’ll make a positive difference to clients facing the challenges of relationship breakdown.”

If you would like to arrange an initial consultation with Morven, please contact us on 0141 420 2430 or email us at reception@flmscotland.co.uk. 

Categories
Children International Family Law

Can a child currently be returned to Ukraine under 1980 Hague Convention?

Can a child currently be returned to Ukraine under the 1980 Hague Convention?

I have had a number of enquiries from parents of children who have come to the UK under the Family Visa Scheme, that the UK has put in place for Ukrainians.  As yet however, none of the enquiries that I have had have proceeded to Court. To my knowledge, the Scottish Court has yet to consider the matter.

The English Court in the case of Q v. R [2022] EWHC 2961 (Fam) was faced with this scenario. A Ukrainian mother sought the return of her child to Ukraine from England.    Two “defences“ were raised on behalf of the Respondent father (1) that the 5 year old child in this case was habitually resident in England at the date of the wrongful retention and therefore the 1980 Convention did not apply and (2) in the event the 1980 Hague Convention did apply Article 13(b) where there is a grave risk that the child’s return would expose him to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place him in an intolerable situation applies, and a non-return should be the outcome.

The Judge having decided, on balance, that the child was habitually resident in Ukraine at the date of his wrongful retention and therefore the 1980 Convention was invoked, moved on to discuss the very relevant Article 13(b) defence.  As can be imagined, the father’s case was very much that given Ukraine is currently in the midst of a war, that the Article 13(b) defence was very clearly made out.   

The Judge was clear that (in his words) “The Authorities indicate a need to focus upon the circumstances of this child returning to that country, and the risks which arise on their return and thereafter.  Protective measures are a relevant consideration; they can take many forms”.  He then went on to analyse evidence that had been lodged by both parties but particularly was careful to take account of the situation on the ground in Ukraine. Ultimately, the mother’s response to the Article 13(b) defence was that the town in which she was intending to return the child to in Ukraine had not been reached by the conflict as it was located in a very western point of Ukraine, it was functioning reasonably normal with schools open, shops open, the Court system functioning etc.  Crucially the mother provided undertakings, one of which was that if the conflict were to extend towards the town she was taking the child to, she would remove the child from Ukraine.  The Judge therefore found that an Article 13(b) defence had not been established and ordered the return of the child to Ukraine.   

While perhaps a surprising Judgment to some, the Judge was very clear that the 1980 Hague Convention and the pertaining case law, is very clear that Judges in these cases have to look at the individual child and the circumstances pertaining to that child.   Even where on the face of it a return to Ukraine would have seemed unlikely, in the circumstances of this particular child allowed the Judge to order the return.

Marisa Cullen

Marisa joined Family Law Matters Scotland LLP as a partner in 2021. Marisa has been practicing law since 2005. She is double accredited by the Law Society of Scotland as a specialist in both family law and child law.

N.B Please note the contents of this Blog do not constitute any form of legal advice and you should always obtain individual advice as to your rights from a family lawyer.

Categories
Children

Autumn Blues

Autumn Blues

For most of us the summer holidays are now a dim and distant memory. The children are back at school, the weather has turned, and the shops are already displaying Hallowe’en and Christmas goodies.

Autumn blues aside, October is a good time to start looking forward to thinking about the arrangements for children over the festive period.

Christmas is a magical time for children, and for those who have parents in separate households, it is important that they are able to spend quality time with all of the people who are important in their lives. It isn’t a case of one size fits all. Much will depend on things like geography, the ages of your children, and other events which are planned. Some families operate a “year about” pattern, so the arrangements for this year may depend on what happened at Christmas 2021. The thing to focus on, is what will work best for your children in their particular circumstances.

It can be very stressful for parents who are unable to reach an agreement, especially for those who need to make an urgent application to the Court in the weeks running up to Christmas, and are unable to make any plans until the Court makes a decision. That situation can also be stressful for the children themselves. However, with some careful consideration at an early stage, factoring in family celebrations and other events and commitments throughout the festive period, it is often possible to agree arrangements with the other parent at an early stage, so that everyone can relax and enjoy this special time.

Whether you have consulted us before or whether you are new to the firm, please do not hesitate to have a chat with one of our expert team if we can assist.

I hope that you all get what you want for Christmas, even if it is just to keep the stress levels to a minimum.

Karen Gailey

Karen qualified as a solicitor in 1992 and has practised exclusively in the areas of family and child law since 2005. She is accredited by the Law Society of Scotland as a specialist in both Family Law and Child Law.

N.B Please note the contents of this Blog do not constitute any form of legal advice and you should always obtain individual advice as to your rights from a family lawyer.

Categories
Children International Family Law

UK Cross Border Child Law

UK Cross Border Child Law

UK cross border child law: My child had been abducted by their father/mother from England to Scotland, what can I do?

I am assuming that both parents have equal parental rights and responsibilities under English law and the child is habitually resident in England. If there is doubt about whether this applies to you, that must be looked at first.

The international parental child abduction convention (the 1980 Hague convention) does not apply to intra UK child abductions. Recourse has to be made to domestic UK law and in this scenario the Family Law Act 1986 applies. Essentially this act allows the parent who has had their children abducted to or wrongfully retained (perhaps after contact) in another UK constituent country to seek their return.

The left behind parent in England will require English child court orders if they do not have them already which are considered “Part 1” orders under the 1986 Act. Urgent advice from an English family solicitor to obtain such orders on an emergency basis will be required (we have a network of family solicitors throughout England to assist with this if needed). Once the part 1 orders are obtained, they can be speedily registered in Scotland and enforcement proceedings can be immediately raised and served.

Once served the defender will usually only have 4 days to provide any written defence and a first hearing is assigned very quickly thereafter. There are very limited defences available to these enforcement proceedings and protective pre-service orders can also be sought if required. There is also a UK judicial network where both sets of judges can liaise with each other regarding the case.

It is crucial that advice from both jurisdictions is sought and both sets of lawyers combine to work urgently to have the child returned. We can assist with the Scottish side of the proceedings (and can act for both the left behind parent and parent faced with such enforcement proceedings) as well as liaising with or arranging English legal advice.

Marisa Cullen

Marisa joined Family Law Matters Scotland LLP as a partner in 2021. Marisa has been practicing law since 2005. She is double accredited by the Law Society of Scotland as a specialist in both family law and child law.

N.B Please note the contents of this Blog do not constitute any form of legal advice and you should always obtain individual advice as to your rights from a family lawyer.

Categories
Children International Family Law

What is Parental Child Abduction?

What is Parental Child Abduction?

When someone says “child abduction”, horrific images of children being kidnapped by strangers comes to mind. However what is less well known is that children can be “abducted” by one of their parents. This can occur when families who have cross border ties separate and one parent takes or retains the child out with the country they normally live in without the consent of the other parent or the court. They may have cogent reasons for doing so and there are defences available to parents in this situation but legally this may still be classed as parental child abduction.

There are different legal rules and procedures that operate when a child is relocated by one parent, without the consent of the other parent, between the different constituent countries of the UK compared with the child being relocated without consent internationally. For international parental child abduction, there are different international conventions that apply and not all countries are signed up to the same international conventions or recognise the conventions at all. 

Separating from your partner and deciding what is best for the children can be even more stressful when you are a cross border family. More often than not, parents who have perhaps relocated to the other parent’s country of origin want to return with the children to what they see as their “home country” but the other parent refuses to provide consent but the child is relocated anyway. Another example of a situation that may be classed as parental child abduction is where parents have separated, the live in different countries and have agreed contact with the non-resident parent during school holidays but the child is not returned after the contact period has come to an end.

It is crucial for both parents, and the children who are caught in the middle of disputes, to have a speedy resolution to their situation. Often legal advice from the two countries involved may be necessary and at FLM we have a large network of both intra UK and international family specialist lawyers who can be quickly brought in to assist with your case. Whether you are a parent thinking about relocating your children; a parent who has relocated your children without consent or a parent who has had their children taken to another country without consent, we can use our experience in international family law to navigate you through your legal options.

Marisa Cullen

Marisa joined Family Law Matters Scotland LLP as a partner in 2021. Marisa has been practicing law since 2005. She is double accredited by the Law Society of Scotland as a specialist in both family law and child law.

N.B Please note the contents of this Blog do not constitute any form of legal advice and you should always obtain individual advice as to your rights from a family lawyer.