Since the
Family Law (Scotland) Act 2006 came into force, former cohabitants in Scotland
have been able to make a claim against each other following separation. Cohabitants
are specifically defined as “a man and a woman who are (or were) living
together as if they were husband and wife or two persons of the same sex who
are (or were) living together as if they were civil partners”.
What can
they claim?
Cohabitants
can claim a capital sum to redress any economic disadvantage suffered as a
result of the contributions they have made to the relationship, and which
disadvantage has not been balanced out by any advantage they have gained from
the other party’s contributions. “Advantage” includes gains in income, capital
and earning capacity and disadvantage is construed accordingly. “Contributions”
include both direct contributions such as payments of money and indirect
contributions such as restricting one’s career and looking after any children
of the relationship. A separate claim can also be made to ensure that the
economic burden of raising any children of the relationship is shared.
Time limit
Although
the 2006 Act is due to be reformed, currently cohabitants only have one year
from the date they separated to make their claim. If that time limit passes
with no action being raised, then the court is unable to accept a late claim.
What next?
The time
limit can create a very unfair situation. For example, cohabitant, “A” may have
sold their house and contributed the proceeds of sale to the purchase of a new
home with cohabitant “B” because they thought they were going to get married
and that, therefore, in the longer term they would share in the value of the
property. However, the title to the property is taken in the name of B alone.
If the parties separate and it has been over a year since separation, A cannot
raise an action against B under the 2006 Act. However, all is not necessarily
lost. A may have the option to make a claim against B under the common law of
unjust enrichment. The likelihood of success will be largely dependent on the
quality of evidence available – something which saw the downfall of the pursuer
in the recent case of Richard Gourlay v Lorna Clark at Dundee Sheriff Court.
The pursuer had no evidence to support his claim and was found to be an
entirely incredible and unreliable witness. Unjust enrichment is, however, a
very complicated area of the law and one upon which expert advice from a
specialist family lawyer is required.
How can I
minimise difficulties that may occur on the breakdown of my cohabiting
relationship?
One of the most common issues that arises when cohabitants separate is
that one party has been paying the mortgage on a property which is in the other
party’s sole name. On separation, the party who has been so contributing may
request a capital sum based on the proportional increase in property value. The
other party may argue that they were simply paying rent and that they have been
advantaged by the relationship in other ways, negating any disadvantage. The associated
legal costs to analyse all the contributions made by each party over the
relationship is significant. Such costs can be minimised by the parties
entering into a Cohabitation Agreement which can set out, for example, in what
shares the mortgage and bills are paid and what, if any, sum will be paid to
one of the parties in the event of separation and exactly how that will be
calculated.
Another common use of the Cohabitation Agreement is where parties are
making unequal contributions to the purchase of a property which is being taken
in joint names. The agreement can set out what those contributions are and how
the value of the property should be divided in the event of
separation. This type of agreement is ideal for the situation where
parents gift money to their children to purchase property and they wish to
ensure that the gift is protected in the event of separation.
A Cohabitation Agreement can therefore provide certainty as to how
certain aspects of any separation will be regulated, alleviating some of the
stress and pain that accompanies that separation and minimising any legal fees.
For advice on cohabitation, unjustified enrichment and other family matters, please contact us on 0141 420 2430 or email us at reception@flmscotland.co.uk.
The content of this webpage is for information only and is not intended to be construed as legal advice and should not be treated as a substitute for specific advice. Family Law Matters Scotland LLP accepts no responsibility for the content of any third party website to which this webpage refers.